Tiny Houses

Is This a Good Idea? The Hour’s Hilary Doyle finds out. Vote on it, go to http://goodidea.cbc.ca/.

177 Comments

  1. I think those little “tumbleweed” houses, as the company calls them, are
    awesome, i want one, and not just for the novelty.

  2. must be near impossible for the hose to keep a constant regular
    temperature, id hate to open the door in the winter…you suck out all the
    haet in 5 seconds! Brrrr!

  3. you can actually by the floor plans for around $700 and build it yourself
    or hire a contractor to do it. We’ve done ours at about $2300.

  4. Hi, Please contact us about building these houses. Our experience is that
    they can’t really be built that cheap. But if you can do it, we’ll hire you
    to build several. You can reach us through the Tumbleweed website.

  5. To sign up for the job please visit Tumbleweed Houses. We don’t pay $40,000
    for labor, but if you think you can build it for $5,000 in materials,
    please contact us. We’d like to hire you!

  6. Plans are $1000. The cost for the trailer alone is $2000. The Dickinson
    marine heater is $1000. The custom made gothic window is $1000. All of the
    stainless steel is $1000. Sure you could use a plastic sink and get off
    cheap but that’s not what he built. He built something nice. It would be
    $15k – $20k in materials to build yourself unless you want a FEMA trailer.

  7. you could make your own even better then that one for like 2,000 bucks and
    biger then his!!! Idiots dont buy these make your own go to lows or home
    depot!!!!

  8. You really want to live in a tool shed? and where would you put said tool
    shed, in your parents back yard? The land is the most expensive part… and
    designing and making a nice liveable structure costs a bit too. I’d say
    more like 30,000. However, i’m not sure where they’re at, and land tends to
    be worth more than people’s homes now a days.

  9. I’d imagine he utilizes a laundromat like many people who currently reside
    in trailers, apartments, and RVs. On the website it does mention you can
    fit a compact, ventless washer/dryer combo into some of the tiny houses. I
    used one of them in my very small NYC studio for 3 years and it was a very
    useful appliance, although it took 2-3 drying cycles to dry heavy things
    like denim. 🙂

  10. bullshit. i built a barn style workshop for $2000 it was two stories
    (loft)and about 20% bigger then this place. drywall and sinks don’t add
    another $38000 pal! good luck in the unemployment line. tops this place
    would run $15,000 not including property but adding property into cost is
    bullshit anyway

  11. Notice you said you built it. Apparently these places are about 23,000
    dollars in material costs (trailer, toilet, sink, stove, wiring, etc.) I
    read it on the site. But Jay owns a business, and–at least in the U.S.
    where these are made–labor cost is a big expense. Companies have to make
    profit. Everybody’s free to build one on their own, but most people don’t
    want to put in the effort because they’re not plumbers, carpenters, or
    electricians.

  12. Notice you said you built it. Apparently these places are about 23,000
    dollars in material costs (trailer, toilet, sink, stove, wiring, etc.) I
    read it on the site. But Jay owns a business, and–at least in the U.S.
    where these are made–labor cost is a big expense. Companies have to make
    profit. Everybody’s free to build one on their own, but most people don’t
    want to put in the effort because they’re not plumbers, carpenters, or
    electricians.

  13. 23,000 in mat for this place agian is very high and adding another 21,000
    for labour totasl absurd . (i live in the US) and if you pay that much your
    insane.

  14. I agree and personally wouldn’t pay that much. Another company is selling a
    trailer house for about half the price of these, but I don’t remember the
    name. Tumbleweed is still around, though, so they’re doing something right.

  15. Maybe the 45,000 includes well and septic? But ya the house itself could be
    built for much less. I could see building one a little bigger though.

  16. Sweet Christ, are some of you people ever inarticulate. I swear, YouTube
    flamers sound very unintelligent at times. Give Jay a break; he has to make
    a profit as a business owner. If you don’t like it, build it yourself for
    less, as he acknowledges is possible. Yes, they are small; they’re also
    high quality, portable, and sustainable. I’d rather have a small,
    efficient, quality house on good land than a waste of space in the dead,
    overpriced suburbs any day.

  17. I love LOVE the idea of having a tiny house, since I don’t want nor need a
    lot of space…and have always dreamed of owning a small home. I think
    Jay’s tiny home is a tad too cramped with his design, and have seen other
    people’s tiny homes (which were cheaper to build and not much larger than
    his) that were set up differently on the inside that made them feel
    roomier. My problem is A.) buying cheap land to put my tiny house on and
    B.) having it built (I’m pretty clueless in that area).

  18. I am guess that he does not have a Costco membership. Eat out a lot? Or do
    you keep food supplies in the pantry in the shed? Notice the Ikea stuff?
    Did you grow up on a sail boat? Do you spend all your time outside?
    Speaking of outside, how about a bit of yard work?

  19. Cool house, but it’s not worth $45K. You can get kits for less than that
    amount. On a side-note, why is this segment associated with a crappy show
    like “The Hour”. Ugh … I still can’t believe they haven’t gotten rid of
    that awful host and his horrible commercials on CBC!

  20. The concept is great for anyone wanting a modest first home however at
    45000 dollars the price is simply rediculous. My guess is that a house like
    that can be built for 10-15k US at the very most.

  21. $ 45K who are you kidding you know what kind of luxury motorhome I can buy
    with $ 45k Is it made of gold ? RIDICULOUS more like $ 4,500

  22. Look at his smile at the end of the video when she tell him it’s expensive
    even him knows that Look like a scam artist I will not trust this guy to
    build my dog house

  23. I built a 650 sq. ft. cabin, fully plumbed, wired and insulated with a
    double floor, half inch poly treated pine over 1/2 inch oak complete with a
    40 gallon water heater and window air / heat unit for $12,450. (I put the
    oak at the bottom for strength. I also tool a butane torch and burned the
    grain of the pine to bring out the grain more and make it look rustic)
    Eithetr this guy doesn’t know value or he’s trying to catch fish….

  24. “I built a 650 sq. ft. cabin […] $12,450.” How much was the labor,
    accomodations, transportation, accounting, and insurance?

  25. that looks AWESOME!!!!!! but you should add maybe 75-100 more sq feet, so
    you could have a water heater and some other things (unless there is one,
    also does the fireplace keep the place warm say if you were in Chicago

  26. Labor…elecrical inspection $175, propane $0 (The co. I bought the tank
    from did the inspection), Water heater, window air/heat unit, wire, PVC,
    light fixtures, toilet and sinks etc from Lowes approx $1,900. New lumber,
    insulation, roofing and paneling also from Lowes approx. $4,500. Used
    lumber, floor joists, door and windows from salvafe yard Approx. $4,000.
    Misc such as paint and varnish $200. Day labor less than $600. Furnished
    with thrift store and transportation…my pickup. You can do it

  27. Are those all labor-cost figures? How many hours of labor, and and what
    rate per hour? “You can do it” I can run a business building 650 sqft
    houses on-site and selling them for $12,450? What’s my profit margin?

  28. Most of the labor was myself and two sons (part time on the sons) I hired a
    guy to do the roof simply because I didn’t want to be crawling around on
    anything with a pitch. Time? Approx. 20-25 hours per week including chasing
    materials. Total rime? Approx. 250 hours or start to finish less than 3
    months. If you were to do it commercially with rwo guys building full time,
    you could put one together in about two weeks but the cost od materials
    would also go up…cont’d

  29. Cont’d…I never intended to build to sell but since them I have added a
    front covered deck. At several BBQ’s I have been told that since it is
    built on blocks, I could sell it and move it easily. We’ve been told that
    sans deck, we could easily sell iy for $22 to 28,000.

  30. To EL90291 I guess in Shangrila things are free. He’s made these cute
    little homes a great business for himself. Labour costs are exorbitant. If
    you want cheaper, build it yourself or buy yourself a mass produce trailer.

  31. oh, and the yard work, yes all the waste water is directed into the garden
    outside where he grows food, so it is recycled. jackass.

  32. why? you obviuosly don’t get it. he’s devoted at least 10 years of his life
    to this. get a clue. how’s that mortgage/rent, and utility bills feeling
    every month? slave.

  33. I’m not claustrophobic but would soon become in a house like this. Is it in
    the Guiness world record yet? Oh! Wait a minute, some people do live in
    spaces smaller with family members. I guess that it’s not that new of a
    concept.

  34. you can do it for a lot less if you put on blocks… and shop craigslist
    for sinks, toilet, etc. – find old mobile homes and pull out propane fridge
    and stove (they’re always tiny) – get creative. i’m about to start one that
    will be permanent. been getting a lot of things 2nd hand, expect to spend
    well under 5k for 8×15. better than living in a 5th wheel with 6.5″
    ceilings… . land is paid off, little house, no bank …yippie freekin ya

  35. Always someone who doesn’t know what they are talking about trying to
    criticize others who think outside the american box. Why watch videos of
    things you aren’t even interested in except to say negative crap? Go away!

  36. I can tell by you ruff estimation of cost that you never shopped at Home
    Depot ( event that isn’t the cheapest alternative) There’s no more than $
    10K in material so you add $ 40 K labor ?!?!?! and you can get all the
    building material for $5k if you have time on hand and use recylced
    material that is more earth friendly anyway

  37. Even if it isn’t, in practice, for everybody, it’s a good idea because we
    need ideas that open our minds a little. We already know that our
    overconsumption leads to enormous problems. What we DON’T know, most of us,
    is what to do about it, where to go from here. Not everyone will live in a
    house this small, but everyone can be inspired to make better use of the
    space they have. Imagination is contagious.

  38. You’re all basically subjects under British rule… They say no guns, you
    have no guns. I think they’re telling you to shut the hell up now…. you’d
    better obey your masters… LOL

  39. You’re all basically subjects under British rule… They say no guns, you
    have no guns. I think they’re telling you to shut the hell up now…. you’d
    better obey your masters… LOL

  40. At The Great American Dollhouse Museum, we have DOLLHOUSES almost this big!
    LOL, I enjoyed the video; thanks for posting it.

  41. $45 000 is very expensive for this house. I built a 98 square foot cob
    building with a cedar shingle roof last summer for around $3000 and could
    have been less is I’d have used on site materials. Add DIY plumbing and
    electrical as well as reused camper/trailer appliances and you are looking
    at less than $5000 for the same space

  42. @mamamaby i dont see why people are giving you a thumbs down. this guy is
    making a fortune off these things. building materials altogether for a
    luxurious tiny house would be max $10,000. That’s a $35,000 profit.

  43. A average house in America is around 2000 sq ft at a cost of about 200,000
    that is $100 sq ft. These tiny houses are 4x more expensive to buy. I think
    a single person could build one for less than 5000.

  44. @Bacicot ….. that was the first question that popped in my head…. how
    do u have sex without breaking the house??

  45. @carnac449 Yeah he is married and has a kid so he built a 500 square foot
    home for space obviously and has this tiny home beside that.

  46. At first I thought it was cool, but it’s way too small. I’m all for
    downsizing, but this is ridiculous. Buy some cheap land and build
    (yourself) a 20 x 20 box, nothing fancy. if you do it yourself for under 20
    grand. visit my channel. we have a growing forum.

  47. @faheemthedream2007 Well, you can build that house for less than 20 grand,
    but he was talking about the price if you buy the house itself from him,
    already built and delivered. If you buy the plans and build it yourself,
    it’s much cheaper.

  48. wow i love to have one for a starter house later i will build up money for
    a middle size my advice it good for a starter house.

  49. 45k? jesus. build one for a fraction of that price. i dont have any doubts
    i could build a comparable portable home for about 5k, if not less, by
    using alot of second hand, or used materials.

  50. There is no way that house cost 45,000. he is using the tube for sales
    promotion. 5000 would be the realistic amount and even then thats all new
    material cost without a discount and the depot or local hardware.

  51. @nomadicslacker I think he’s taking labor into account. He’s said that the
    materials cost for his house was around $15k. That still might seem high,
    but that includes the trailer and all of the hardware in the place. I’ll be
    building one of these as soon as I can (which will be a lot sooner than the
    time I could ever afford a “real” house)

  52. @nomadicslacker I think he’s taking labor into account. He’s said that the
    materials cost for his house was around $15k and that it took about 500
    hours of (his own) labor to build. That still might seem high, but that
    includes the trailer and all of the hardware in the place. I’ll be building
    one of these as soon as I can (which will be a lot sooner than the time I
    could ever afford a “real” house)

  53. i cant wait until i build mine 🙂 ill trade you a 30+ year mortgage,
    headaches, debt etc and raise u a simple life with more free time and more
    of your hard earn money going in your pocket 🙂 o how we’ve been decieved
    🙁 lol live in one of these for a couple of year and with all the money u
    would have saved you can pay of your car in full buy a cozy house cash!!
    and take that dream vacation 🙂 ohh the possibilities are endless…

  54. The biggest question of all….what about people with CHILDREN? I would
    love to buy a house like this, but I guess I’d have to sell it once I get
    little ones

  55. @InuvikPhil I have kids but I could never live in one that small with
    really little ones. I’m obsessed with these now and hope to get one (they
    do come in larger sizes, see their website) as soon as the kids are older
    and out (ha!). My husband & I would love to have one for the two of us –
    lots of traveling in our futures!

  56. @1UnstableMind The tiny house doesn’t seem like a bad idea if you live in
    great weather and have a good, sturdy car. And are single for the rest of
    your life. It seems great. I guess even if you get married and have kids,
    you can always keep it for the tough times lol

  57. overpriced. you could build one of these yourself with retail prices on
    lumber and everything from Home Depot and probably pay 1/3 to 1/2 the price.

  58. How does the toilet work on these? If it doesn’t have plumbing does it just
    go in a hole in the floor or have some kind of RV type system?

  59. @vutEwa They sell plans on the tinyhouse website and have a diy section. I
    would pay 1/2 for the connivence of not having to do it myself and knowing
    it was done right because the last thing I made from wood was a paper towel
    holder. Make sure you factor in the price of the trailer, too.

  60. @vutEwa He said in another video it cost him about 17000 for the materials
    and 500 working hours… so yes it’s a lot cheaper if you do it your self
    but… I don’t know I’ve never been very handy with building stuff so for
    someone like me, it’d probably be worth the extra money to make sure it
    wont collapse the next time the winds pick up 😛

  61. You guys are away he probably pays about five dollars a year in utilities,
    right? It might be slightly pricey, but the savings make up for it over
    time. Part of that whole large investment for long-lasting benefit certain
    parties would call a waste of money.

  62. That house isn’t so tiny. It is big enough for one Native American family
    or two Japanese families or three Mexican families.

  63. Shit. Period. I rather live in a shack that cost about 1$ and use $1,000 to
    make a better house tomorrow. $45,000 for that piece of con. Who the fine
    lady though.

  64. People haven’t been to his website and read his book. He built this thing
    for around $20,000 (since he did all the labor) but he sells the ready made
    version for $45,000. But you can buy the plans and built it for $20,000 as
    well. And much of that cost is just the high quality finish.

  65. @crewlla yeah, but you also have to consider the other side of that coin.
    People who spent 130,000 dollars on a house now owe the bank that much for
    a house worth 50,000… But yes, 40,000 is outrageously expensive, but
    people have built them themselves for 20,000… and 12,000 with
    reused/recycled materials which is MUCH more manageble.

  66. @BlueStrikeP I wish they would come up with a design that can withhold
    tempertures of -40 or -50 with out any thing frezzing in the middle of the
    night. ( I live in the coldest province in canada) the only thing that
    comes close is a trailer or manufatured home. but they cost as much as a
    house does. the idea is awesome in theroy but it just wont work were I am
    from. maybe tiny homes can work on that idea. I have a son who I think
    needs to be on his own. 😉

  67. @crewlla yeah that’s rough, I can’t think of anything significantly
    efficient that wouldn’t be somewhat into the ground for insulative
    purposes. I live in the midwest of the US so our tempts don’t get anywhere
    near as cold as that. But where there is a will, there is a way. Maybe you
    migrate with the weather? Personally I’d like a hyper efficient small home
    built into the earth, use the earth to cover you up! Challenges, both
    environmental and financial are chances to get creative.

  68. for 45k you can have a debt free, eco-friendly, traveling house. sounds
    good to me but i may just be retarded. then again, you can build it
    yourself and save 25k. my future home right there

  69. Sorry, but for $45K, you can do sooooo much better than this, if what you
    want is to have a house like this, I understand, but if you have $45K and
    looking for an affordable place to live, $45K wil get 3 times this space
    and comfort, yet still mobile, since you can get a 14×24, 2 story bard/shed
    for $10K, that’s about 600sf, finish it inside with cabinets, shower and
    furnish it for under $30K, I tell you cuz that’s what my brother in law did!

  70. I live in a traditional house and it was 36 thousand and that’s expensive
    enough. I think buying one of these things would be like hiring someone to
    drive your car so you have a place to put your briefcase as you bicycle to
    work because you think it helps the environment and economy.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*